Best Renters Insurance Companies
Do you believe renters insurance is only for older, wealthy individuals with high-end furniture or art collections?
If so, you’ve fallen for one of the most common misconceptions about renters insurance. Without essential personal liability protection for your belongings, you could be taking unnecessary financial risks.
True peace of mind is invaluable — and the good news is that protecting yourself from potential financial setbacks is more affordable than you might imagine. There are many budget-friendly renters insurance options available to suit your needs.
Renters Insurance Companies are:
1. Amica: Best Overall
Available In: All U.S. states except Hawaii
Complaint Volume: 42 in the past 12 months
Amica stands out for its affordable and customer-oriented renters insurance. Premiums can start at less than $4 per week, though the actual cost depends on factors such as your location, coverage amount, and optional add-ons.
The company offers a fast and straightforward application process, often allowing you to secure a policy within minutes. Amica also provides up to a 15% discount when you bundle multiple policies like auto, life, or umbrella insurance.
Additionally, Amica rewards loyalty — you can qualify for a loyalty discount if you’ve maintained insurance coverage (with any provider) for at least two years. A claim-free discount is also available for customers who haven’t filed any claims in the last three years.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Low premiums | Fewer discounts than some competitors |
| Loyalty discount | Costs extra for replacement cost coverage of personal belongings |
| Rapid application process |
2. Erie Insurance: Best Bundle Discount
Available In: Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wisconsin
Complaint Volume: 73 in the past 12 months
Erie Insurance is highly regarded for offering some of the best bundle discounts in the industry. By combining your renters policy with other plans — such as auto, business , or life insurance — you can save up to 25% on your premiums.
With a strong network of over 13,000 independent agents, Erie provides personalized support and service across its coverage areas. The company earned the second-highest ranking in J.D. Power’s 2020 home insurance satisfaction study, highlighting its reputation for excellent customer care.
Erie currently manages more than 6,000 active home, auto, and business insurance policies, reflecting its stability and commitment to policyholders.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Many coverage options | No online quotes |
| Opportunities for discounts | Limited state availability |
| Customization options available |
3. Lemonade: Best Online Application Process
Available In: 28 states
Complaint Volume: 173 in the past 12 months
Lemonade is a modern, tech-driven insurance company known for its fast and fully digital renters insurance process. With a simple, user-friendly online platform, you can apply for coverage and get approved in just 90 seconds — far quicker than most traditional insurers.
Renters insurance policies with Lemonade start as low as $5 per month, making it an affordable option for many. The company also uses advanced AI to streamline claims, often processing and paying them at exceptional speed.
If you’re looking for a hassle-free, transparent, and quick online experience, Lemonade’s renters insurance stands out as one of the most efficient options available today.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Pays claims fast | Not available everywhere |
| Low-cost policies | A lot of customer complaints |
| Includes unique coverage, like water damage of your belongings |
4. State Farm: Best Local Agent Network
Available In: Nationwide
Complaint Volume: 1,699 in the past 12 months
State Farm ranks among the largest insurance providers in the U.S. and is well-known for its extensive local agent network, featuring nearly 19,000 agents across the country. While you can easily manage or purchase a renters insurance policy online, having access to a nearby agent offers valuable, in-person support when needed.
State Farm’s renters insurance policies come with flexible add-on options, including earthquake and flood protection, as well as scheduled personal property coverage for high-value items.
Customers can enjoy savings of up to 17% when bundling renters and auto insurance. Additionally, State Farm offers inflation coverage, helping your policy maintain consistent value even during periods of rising costs.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Available nationwide | Must go through an agent |
| Offers inflation coverage | Large number of complaints |
| Offers many coverage options |
5. Country Financial: Best Option for Discounts
Available In: 20 states
Complaint Volume: 37 in the past 12 months
Country Financial provides renters insurance with Basic and Premier coverage options, allowing you to choose a plan that fits your needs. Basic coverage protects against common risks like fire, theft, vandalism, wind, and frozen pipes, while Premier coverage adds protections for things such as power surges and accidental damage like spilled paint.
Policies can be tailored with actual cash value or replacement cost coverage, helping cover the cost of replacing expensive items as prices rise. The company also offers coverage for high-value possessions and flood damage.
Discounts are available for bundling renters insurance with auto or life policies, maintaining a claim-free record for five years, consistent timely payments over three years, or demonstrating loyalty to Country Financial.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Low complaint volume | No online quote option |
| Many discount options | Not available everywhere |
| Many options for coverage |
6. American Family: Best for Customized Policies
Available In: 19 states
Complaint Volume: 91 in the past 12 months
American Family provides flexible renters insurance policies that can be tailored with a variety of add-ons. Standard coverage includes personal property protection, personal liability, and additional living expenses if a covered disaster occurs. What sets American Family apart is the range of optional coverages not commonly offered by other insurers, such as protection for pets, travel, home-based businesses, sewer backup, identity theft, and credit monitoring.
The company also provides multiple ways to save, including loyalty, paperless, autopay, and full-pay discounts, making it easier to customize coverage while staying within budget.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Ways to save money | Not available everywhere |
| Online quotes available | Add-ons can make your rental insurance costly |
| Unique opportunities for add-on coverage |
7. USAA: Best for Military Families
Available In: Nationwide
Complaint Volume: 1,710 in the past 12 months
USAA provides affordable renters insurance tailored for military members and their families, with premiums starting at just 33 cents per day. The company is known for its award-winning customer service and a smooth, efficient claims process. USAA policies are portable, offering coverage for your belongings wherever you are stationed.
A standout feature is automatic replacement cost coverage, which ensures damaged items are replaced at full value without depreciation deductions. Military families can also access multiple discounts, including bundle discounts, claim-free savings up to 20% for three years, a 28% discount for living on base, and up to 45% off for those enrolled in a U.S. military service academy.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Affordable premiums | Must be a USAA member |
| Includes flood damage | Doesn’t cover all water damage |
| Offers significant discounts for military families |
8. Allstate: Best for Policy Add-Ons
Available In: Nationwide
Complaint Volume: 1,641 in the past 12 months
Allstate is a well-established insurer often compared to State Farm, offering a range of unique add-on options for renters insurance. These include identity theft restoration coverage and umbrella insurance, which can be especially valuable for pet owners in multi-unit buildings.
By bundling renters insurance with an Allstate auto policy, premiums can be as low as $4 per month. Standard coverage also includes guest medical protection for injuries on your property and additional living expenses if you need temporary housing while your home is being repaired.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Covers guest injuries | Low customer satisfaction ratings |
| Offers bundled package pricing | Coverage may cost more than other insurance companies |
| Includes identity theft restoration coverage and umbrella insurance |
9. Nationwide: Best for Actual Cash Value Replacement Coverage
Available In: 47 states
Complaint Volume: 95 in the past 12 months
Nationwide offers renters insurance with comprehensive coverage that often exceeds what many competitors provide. Standard policies protect against theft, natural disasters, bodily injury, and water backup damage, among other risks.
Additional features include credit card coverage to protect against unauthorized debit or credit transactions. For those seeking extra protection, Nationwide offers the Brand New Belongings add-on, which provides replacement cost coverage. This means damaged or stolen items are reimbursed at the cost of buying new replacements, rather than their depreciated cash value, offering significant peace of mind and potentially saving thousands after a covered loss.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Customizable options | Not available in all states |
| Online quotes available | Not transparent about its discounts |
| Includes earthquake coverage |
10. Farmers Insurance: Best for Professional Discounts
Available In: Nationwide
Complaint Volume: Not available
Farmers Insurance stands out for offering premium discounts to certain professionals, such as firefighters and teachers. Availability and amounts vary by location, but these discounts provide extra savings for many hardworking renters.
Additional discounts include smoke-free household savings (after two years), bundling discounts, and reductions for having security or fire alarm systems. Policies can also be customized with personal article floaters, which cover individual items valued over $500, giving renters added protection for their most valuable belongings.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Online quote capabilities | Not all discounts are available nationwide |
| Many ways to get discounts | Premiums can be higher than other companies |
| Discounts for public service professionals |
11. Policygenius: Best Online Renters Insurance Broker
State availability:Â Nationwide
Complaint volume:Â 8 in the last 12 months
The quote aggregator Policygenius doesn’t issue its own policies, but it’s worth including on this list.
Policygenius walks you through the policy-building process, helping you save time by selecting from a range of coverages, deductibles, and add-ons and receiving quotes from multiple providers.
You’ll get a slew of renters insurance offers in an easy-to-understand format, making it painless to select the most cost-effective policy without sifting through emails or spending hours on the phone.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Is free to use | Doesn’t issue its own policies |
| Provides options for customized policies | You may have to work with an agent in person or on the phone |
| Makes shopping for renter’s insurance easy |
Conclusion
Renters insurance is an essential safeguard for protecting your belongings, personal liability, and peace of mind — no matter your age, income, or the value of your possessions. From budget-friendly options like Lemonade and USAA to comprehensive coverage with Nationwide and State Farm, there’s a policy to fit every need and lifestyle. Many insurers also offer discounts for bundling policies, claim-free records, and professional affiliations, making coverage more affordable than ever. Choosing the right renters insurance ensures you’re financially protected against unexpected events, giving you confidence and security in your home.
